James Gunn’s take on Superman presents the iconic hero as an outsider, but his sharpest political commentary is actually found in the character of Peacemaker.
James Gunn’s Signature Style
Director James Gunn has built his career by telling stories about the unconventional and the outcast. From his early horror-comedies to the beloved Guardians of the Galaxy and his DC work, he infuses superhero narratives with an oddball energy.
This unique approach extends to Superman, traditionally America’s favorite hero. Gunn reimagines him not just as an alien, but as an “immigrant” and an outsider, grappling with identity issues that are external and visible, a departure from previous interpretations.
Superman’s Modern Reimagining
Unlike Zack Snyder’s grittier portrayal where Superman’s struggles were often internalized, Gunn focuses on the hero’s outward conflicts. His Lex Luthor, for instance, is a big tech mogul, mirroring concerns about narrative control in modern society.
Gunn’s Superman prioritizes saving every individual life, reflecting a focus on civilian well-being over grand nationalistic gestures. Despite his Kryptonian origins, Superman’s true power lies in his choices, embracing his humanity and rejecting the idea of lording over others.
Peacemaker: A Deeper Dive into Politics
While Superman offers hints of political commentary, Gunn’s most profound critique of America’s political landscape comes through Peacemaker. Introduced in The Suicide Squad, this anti-hero claims to seek peace at all costs, even through brutal violence.
Peacemaker is an “insider” who ironically harms his own country, embodying a paradoxical patriotism. This character allowed Gunn to explore complex themes more thoroughly, especially in the subsequent HBO spin-off series.
Unpacking Peacemaker’s Complexities
The Peacemaker series delves into the character’s troubled past, marked by a white supremacist father reminiscent of “Uncle Sam.” His internal battle to overcome this toxic upbringing is central to his journey.
Despite his desire for peace, years of conditioning lead him to violence. His companion, Eagly, a bald eagle, symbolizes America itself – an animal that preys but also soars, offering a path beyond confined nationalistic views.
Peacemaker’s arc sees him confront not only external threats but also his ingrained biases. He ultimately seeks a universal peace, moving beyond a narrow, violent definition of national interest. This deep internal and external transformation makes Peacemaker Gunn’s most nuanced political statement.
- James Gunn portrays Superman as an “alien” and “immigrant,” externalizing his identity conflict.
- Gunn’s Superman focuses on individual lives and personal choice over nationalistic ideals.
- Peacemaker offers a more profound and layered commentary on American identity and the paradox of seeking peace through violence.
Both characters reflect aspects of American identity, but Peacemaker’s extended narrative allowed for a truly immersive and critical exploration of the country’s complexities.
